Insurance Company Won’t Call Me Back After Reporting a Cincinnati Car Crash

by Injury Law Support | Jan 6, 2025

After a collision in Cincinnati, accident victims rely on your insurance provider to guide you through the claims process and help you recover financially. But what happens when your calls go unanswered, emails are ignored, or you’re left in the dark? This lack of communication can delay repairs, medical bill payments, and, ultimately, your ability to move forward. In this article, we’ll explore your options if your insurance company refuses to return your calls and outline the steps you can take to protect your rights and ensure your claim is handled properly.

The Importance of Timely Communication with Insurance Companies
Reasons Why Insurance Companies May Delay Responses
Steps to Take if Your Insurance Company Doesn’t Respond
Why It Is Important to Document Your Contact Attempts
When to Consider Filing a Formal Complaint
What Is The Role of an Insurance Agent or Claims Adjuster?
Understanding Your Rights Under Ohio Insurance Law
When To Seek Legal Assistance for an Unresponsive Insurance Company?
Are There Alternatives to Reach a Settlement Without Your Insurer’s Cooperation?
What Are Some Preventative Tips for Better Communication with Insurers in Future Claims?

The Importance of Timely Communication with Insurance Companies

Timely communication with your insurance company can make all the difference when it comes to resolving claims quickly and efficiently. Whether you’ve been involved in a car accident, experienced property damage, or are dealing with another insured event, the way you communicate—and how soon you do so—can significantly impact the outcome of your claim.

Why Timing Matters

Insurance claims often follow strict deadlines. Most policies require you to report incidents promptly, and delays in communication can jeopardize your ability to receive compensation. When you wait too long, it not only slows down the claims process but may also raise red flags for the insurer, who could view the delay as a potential red flag for fraud or inaccuracies.

On the flip side, reaching out to your insurance company immediately shows diligence and commitment to resolving the issue. This proactive approach allows the claims adjuster to investigate your situation thoroughly while details are still fresh, helping ensure a fair assessment.

Preventing Miscommunication

Timely communication also helps minimize misunderstandings. If too much time passes, you might forget important details or lose supporting evidence, such as photos of the damage or witness statements. Insurance companies rely on accurate information to process your claim, and providing updates quickly keeps everyone on the same page.

In cases where you need repairs, medical care, or reimbursement, staying in close contact ensures you’re not left waiting for weeks without answers. Regular follow-ups can prevent your claim from slipping through the cracks.

Protecting Your Rights

When insurers don’t respond in a timely manner, it can feel frustrating and overwhelming. However, staying persistent and documenting all attempts to communicate is essential. If your insurance company fails to meet their obligations, your documentation can serve as critical evidence if you need to escalate the matter through legal or regulatory channels.

Brake check accident?
Contact us today.

Reasons Why Insurance Companies May Delay Responding to You

Unfortunately, delayed responses from insurance companies are more common than many people realize. While it might feel like they’re ignoring you, there are several reasons why an insurer may not respond as quickly as you’d like. Understanding these reasons can help you take the right steps to protect your claim and ensure the process moves forward.

High Volume of Claims – One of the most common reasons for delays is a high volume of claims. Natural disasters, severe weather events, or large-scale accidents can overwhelm insurance companies, leaving their adjusters struggling to keep up. While this may explain some delays, it doesn’t excuse a complete lack of communication. If you’re affected, staying persistent and patient is key, but don’t hesitate to escalate your concerns if necessary.
Incomplete or Missing Information – Insurance companies often require detailed documentation to process a claim. If key information—like a police report, medical records, or photos of the damage—is missing, the insurer may pause the process until you provide it. These delays can often be avoided by carefully reviewing your policy and submitting all required documents upfront.
Internal Bureaucracy – Large insurance companies often have complex organizational structures. Your claim may need to pass through multiple departments, including adjusters, investigators, and legal teams, before a decision is made. This bureaucracy can cause significant delays, especially if your claim is considered complicated or unusual.
Questions About Liability – If there’s any uncertainty about who is at fault in an accident or claim, the insurance company may delay their response while conducting an investigation. For example, if multiple parties are involved in a car crash, the insurer will need to gather statements, review evidence, and determine liability before proceeding. These investigations can take time, but it’s important to stay on top of your claim to ensure they’re not dragging their feet.
Deliberate Delay Tactics – Unfortunately, some delays are intentional. Insurance companies are businesses, and minimizing payouts is in their financial interest. Delaying a claim might push a policyholder to accept a lower settlement out of frustration or financial necessity. While this practice can be unethical, it’s not uncommon. If you suspect deliberate stalling, it’s time to consult a legal professional to ensure your rights are protected.
Disputes Over Coverage – Delays can also arise if there’s a disagreement about what your policy covers. The insurance company may spend extra time reviewing your policy, searching for exclusions, or trying to find ways to deny the claim. If you believe your coverage is being misrepresented, you may need to provide additional evidence or seek legal advice.
Claims Adjuster Turnover – Staffing issues, such as high turnover among claims adjusters, can cause delays. If your adjuster is reassigned or leaves the company, your claim may end up in limbo until another adjuster takes over. Regular follow-ups can help prevent your claim from being forgotten during such transitions.
Financial or Legal Challenges – In rare cases, insurance companies themselves may face financial or legal difficulties that impact their ability to process claims efficiently. For example, an insurer in financial trouble may delay payouts to manage cash flow. If you suspect this is the case, you can report the issue to your state’s insurance regulator for assistance.

What Can You Do About Delays?

If your insurance company is delaying responses, you don’t have to accept it passively. Here are some steps you can take:

Document Everything: Keep records of every phone call, email, and communication attempt.
Follow Up Regularly: Persistence often encourages faster action.
Know Your Policy: Familiarize yourself with the terms of your policy to address any disputes or miscommunications.
Escalate If Necessary: Contact a supervisor, file a complaint with your state insurance department, or seek legal help if the delays persist.

Delays from insurance companies can be stressful, but understanding the reasons behind them can help you stay proactive and in control. By staying organized and persistent, you can navigate these challenges and ensure your claim is handled fairly and efficiently.

Steps to Take if Your Insurance Company Doesn’t Respond

If your insurance company doesn’t respond, there are actionable steps you can take to regain control of the situation and ensure your rights are protected.

Double-Check Your Communication

Before jumping to conclusions, ensure you’ve provided all the necessary information and used the correct contact methods. Confirm that:

The claim was filed with accurate details.
All required documents, such as photos, accident reports, and receipts, have been submitted.
You’re reaching out to the right department or claims adjuster.

Proactively reviewing your correspondence can help avoid unnecessary delays caused by simple oversights.

Follow Up Regularly

Insurance companies manage thousands of claims, and sometimes a follow-up is all it takes to get yours moving. Here’s how to follow up effectively:

Call the Claims Department: Ask to speak directly with your assigned adjuster or their supervisor.
Use Email: Written communication creates a paper trail, which is valuable if the issue escalates.
Be Persistent: Make it clear that you’re serious about resolving the matter by following up regularly.

Keep a log of every attempt to contact your insurer, noting dates, times, and the person you spoke to, if applicable.

Request a Written Timeline

If the insurance company continues to delay, request a written timeline for your claim. A written response not only demonstrates accountability but also ensures there’s a record of the insurer’s promises and obligations. Polite but firm language can emphasize your expectation for a timely resolution.

Escalate Within the Insurance Company

If your adjuster is unresponsive, escalate your concerns to a higher level:

Ask to speak with a supervisor or manager.
Contact the insurance company’s customer service or complaints department.
Refer to your policy for any specific instructions regarding disputes or delays.

Many insurers have internal escalation processes designed to address unresolved claims more efficiently.

File a Complaint with Your State’s Insurance Department

Every state has a regulatory body that oversees insurance companies and protects consumers. If your insurance company fails to respond, file a formal complaint with your state’s Department of Insurance. When filing a complaint:

Provide all relevant documentation, including your claim number and details of your communication attempts.
Outline the specific problem, such as lack of communication or failure to meet deadlines.

State regulators often intervene on behalf of consumers, which can encourage the insurer to act promptly.

Consult an Attorney

If your insurer’s lack of response causes significant financial harm or if you suspect they’re acting in bad faith, consult an attorney who specializes in insurance law. Signs of bad faith include:

Denying your claim without a valid reason.
Deliberately delaying the process to avoid payment.
Failing to communicate within reasonable timeframes.

An experienced Cincinnati car accident attorney can help you file a legal claim against the insurer if necessary, ensuring your rights are upheld.

Know Your Rights

Insurance companies are legally required to act in good faith and adhere to specific timeframes for responding to claims. Most states have laws outlining these obligations, such as providing initial acknowledgment of a claim within a set number of days. Research your state’s regulations to understand what’s considered reasonable response time.

Explore Alternative Dispute Resolution

If the issue persists, consider mediation or arbitration to resolve your claim. These methods allow you to work with a neutral third party to negotiate a resolution without going to court. Some insurance policies even include arbitration clauses, so review your policy for details.

Stay Professional and Persistent

While frustration is natural, staying calm and professional in all your interactions with the insurance company is essential. A composed and factual approach will strengthen your case and make it easier to escalate if needed.

Need Help?
Contact us today.

Why It Is Important to Document Your Contact Attempts?

Whether you’re following up on a car accident claim, seeking clarification on a policy, or disputing a decision, keeping a record of every communication attempt can make the difference between a successful resolution and a drawn-out battle.

Here’s why documentation matters and how it can safeguard your interests.

Creates a Clear Record of Accountability – Documenting your contact attempts establishes a timeline that holds everyone involved accountable. Insurance companies, for example, are often legally required to respond to claims within a specific timeframe. If they delay or ignore your requests, your records can provide proof of when you reached out, how many attempts you made, and whether their response (or lack thereof) violated regulations.
- This accountability can be crucial if the issue escalates to a formal complaint or legal action.
Helps Prevent Miscommunication – In any complex process, miscommunication can easily derail progress. A claims adjuster might say one thing during a phone call, only for the outcome to differ entirely. By keeping detailed records—such as the date, time, and content of conversations—you create a reliable reference point to clarify what was discussed and agreed upon.
- This prevents misunderstandings and ensures that you and the other party stay on the same page throughout the process.
Strengthens Your Case in Disputes – If you find yourself in a dispute with an insurance company or other party, thorough documentation can be a powerful tool. Records of your contact attempts can demonstrate that you’ve been proactive, persistent, and cooperative, while also highlighting the other party’s delays or lack of communication.
- For example:
  - A log of unanswered emails or unreturned calls can show that you’ve made reasonable efforts to resolve the matter.
  - Detailed notes from phone conversations can provide evidence of promises made or inaccurate information given.
  - This level of detail can significantly strengthen your position if the dispute escalates to a regulator, mediator, or court.
Saves Time and Reduces Stress – In a high-stakes situation, the last thing you want is to waste time trying to recall dates, conversations, or contact methods. By keeping organized records of your communication attempts, you have everything you need at your fingertips.
- For example:
  - If an adjuster claims you never contacted them, you can reference your log to confirm when and how you reached out.
  - If your claim is transferred to a new representative, your documentation ensures that you don’t have to start from scratch.
  - Having a clear record reduces stress, eliminates guesswork, and allows you to focus on resolving your claim instead of untangling unnecessary confusion.
Demonstrates Good Faith and Diligence – When dealing with an insurance company, proving that you’ve acted in good faith is essential. A well-documented communication log shows that you’ve made consistent, genuine efforts to engage with the process. This can be especially important if the other party accuses you of neglecting your responsibilities or failing to provide information.
- Additionally, detailed records make it harder for the other party to dismiss or downplay your concerns, as your diligence demonstrates that you take the matter seriously.
Protects You from Unethical Practices – Unfortunately, some companies might engage in tactics designed to delay or discourage claims, such as claiming they never received your correspondence or failing to follow up as promised. Without documentation, it becomes your word against theirs.

By documenting your contact attempts, you protect yourself from these practices. A simple log of emails, call records, or certified mail receipts can challenge attempts to shift blame or stall the process.

How to Effectively Document Your Contact Attempts

Keep a Log: Use a notebook, spreadsheet, or app to record the date, time, and method of each contact attempt. Include the name of the person you spoke with and a summary of the conversation.
Save Written Correspondence: Retain copies of emails, letters, and chat transcripts. If you send documents by mail, use certified mail with a return receipt.
Record Call Details: Take notes during or immediately after phone calls. Note key details, such as promises made or questions answered.
Follow Up in Writing: After phone calls, consider sending a follow-up email summarizing the conversation. This creates a written record that can be referenced later.

When Should I Consider Filing a Formal Complaint With The Insurance Company?

While most issues can be resolved through persistence and communication, there are times when filing a formal complaint becomes the best or even the only option to ensure your rights are respected. Knowing when and how to take this step can make a significant difference in resolving your dispute effectively.

When Your Attempts to Communicate Are Ignored – If you’ve made multiple attempts to contact a company—whether by phone, email, or other means—and they consistently fail to respond, it may be time to escalate the issue. A lack of communication not only delays the resolution of your claim or issue but may also signal that the company is neglecting its legal or ethical obligations. Filing a formal complaint can compel the company to take your concerns seriously and respond in a timely manner.
When Promises Are Not Followed Through – Sometimes, a company might acknowledge your concerns but fail to follow through on their promises. For example:

- An insurance adjuster agrees to provide an update by a specific date but doesn’t.
- A representative promises a payment or resolution, yet nothing happens.
- In such cases, documenting the broken promises and filing a complaint can hold the company accountable and push them to deliver on their commitments.

When Deadlines Are Missed – Most industries, particularly insurance, operate under strict timelines for processing claims, providing updates, or issuing payments. If the company fails to meet these deadlines without providing a valid reason, it may be violating state or federal regulations. Filing a formal complaint with a regulatory body, such as your state’s Department of Insurance, can prompt the company to take immediate corrective action.
When You Suspect Bad Faith Practices – Bad faith occurs when a company deliberately delays, denies, or mishandles your claim without a legitimate reason. Examples include:

- Denying a valid claim without explanation.
- Offering a settlement far below what your policy covers.
- Failing to investigate your claim in a timely or thorough manner.
- If you suspect bad faith practices, filing a formal complaint can protect your rights and alert regulators to potential misconduct.

When the Company Refuses to Resolve the Issue – If you’ve provided all the necessary documentation and complied with every request, yet the company refuses to resolve your issue, it’s time to escalate. A formal complaint signals that you’re serious about holding them accountable. In many cases, this can prompt a resolution without the need for further legal action.
When You’re Facing Financial or Emotional Stress – Delays in resolving a claim or dispute can create significant financial strain or emotional stress, especially if it involves time-sensitive issues like medical bills, home repairs, or lost wages. Filing a formal complaint can expedite the process, giving you the support you need to move forward.
When Regulatory or Legal Intervention Is Needed – In some cases, resolving a dispute may require oversight from a regulatory agency or legal action. Filing a formal complaint with the appropriate organization ensures that your issue is on record and that the company is held accountable for their actions. Regulatory bodies often investigate complaints and enforce penalties when companies fail to comply with industry standards or laws.

How to File a Formal Complaint

If you’ve decided to take this step, here’s how to proceed effectively:

Gather Documentation:
- Collect all relevant information, including correspondence, claim details, policy documents, and evidence of the issue.
Contact the Company One Last Time:
- Inform them that you’re filing a formal complaint if the issue isn’t resolved promptly. Sometimes, this final warning motivates action.
File with the Appropriate Regulatory Agency:
- For insurance disputes, file with your state’s Department of Insurance.
- For general consumer complaints, contact the Better Business Bureau (BBB) or your state’s Attorney General’s Office.
Be Clear and Specific:
- When filing the complaint, outline the issue, provide a timeline of events, and include all supporting documentation.
Follow Up:
- Keep track of your complaint’s status and respond to any requests for additional information.

The Impact of Filing a Formal Complaint

Filing a formal complaint often prompts companies to act quickly to avoid regulatory penalties or public scrutiny. It also helps ensure that your issue is documented and taken seriously. In some cases, it can lead to broader changes, such as policy adjustments or increased oversight, benefiting not just you but other consumers as well.

Insurance Claim?
Contact us today.

What Is The Role of an Insurance Agent or Claims Adjuster?

An insurance agent is your first point of contact when you purchase an insurance policy. Think of them as the bridge between you and the insurance company. Their primary role is to help you select the right coverage and provide ongoing support throughout the life of your policy.

Key Responsibilities of an Insurance Agent:

Explaining Coverage Options: Insurance agents help you understand your coverage needs, such as liability, property, or health insurance. They break down the fine print so you can make an informed decision.
Selling Insurance Policies: Agents work with one or more insurance companies to sell policies that match your specific needs. They’ll help you choose a plan that balances coverage and affordability.
Answering Policy Questions: If you have questions about your policy, such as coverage limits or exclusions, your insurance agent is there to clarify and explain.
Adjusting Coverage: Over time, your insurance needs may change. Agents help you update your policy to reflect changes in your life, such as buying a new car, adding a family member, or increasing coverage for valuable items.
Customer Advocacy: While agents work for the insurance company, many act as advocates for their customers by ensuring policies meet their needs and by offering guidance when filing a claim.

While agents are critical for setting up your policy and providing general support, their role typically ends once you file a claim. That’s when a claims adjuster steps in.

Understanding Your Rights Under Ohio Insurance Law

Ohio has specific laws and regulations in place to protect policyholders and ensure that insurance companies handle claims fairly and ethically. By knowing your rights, you can confidently navigate the insurance process and hold your insurer accountable if something goes wrong.

The Right to a Fair Claims Process
The Right to Clear and Accurate Policy Information
The Right to Timely Communication
The Right to Appeal a Denied Claim
The Right to Be Free From Discrimination
The Right to Work With an Attorney
The Right to File a Complaint
The Right to Prompt Payment for Valid Claims
The Right to Protection Against Fraud

If you ever feel your rights are being violated, take action – whether it’s filing a complaint, consulting legal counsel, or advocating for yourself directly with your insurer. Knowing your rights is the first step toward protecting them.

Insurance issues?
Contact Injury Law Support.

When To Seek Legal Assistance for an Unresponsive Insurance Company

While some delays can be attributed to administrative issues or high claim volumes, persistent silence or intentional delays can indicate deeper issues—potentially bad faith practices. Knowing when to involve a lawyer can help protect your rights and ensure your claim is handled appropriately.

When Repeated Attempts to Communicate Have Failed – If you’ve made multiple attempts to contact your insurance company—via phone calls, emails, or letters—and have received no response, it’s a clear red flag. An unresponsive insurer can delay critical steps, such as investigating your claim, determining liability, or issuing payment. If your attempts at communication are ignored, a lawyer can step in to demand answers and ensure the company complies with their obligations.
When Deadlines Are Missed – Ohio insurance law, like most state laws, requires insurance companies to meet specific timelines during the claims process. For example:
Acknowledging your claim: Insurers must typically acknowledge a claim within a set number of days.
Investigating the claim: They are expected to investigate claims promptly and notify you of their decision.
Processing payment: If a claim is approved, payment must be made within a reasonable timeframe.
If your insurer fails to meet these deadlines, it may be time to consult a lawyer who can evaluate whether the delays are reasonable or if the company is violating state law.
When the Lack of Response Causes Financial or Emotional Hardship – Delays in the claims process can create significant challenges, especially if you’re dealing with medical bills, repair costs, or lost wages. If your insurer’s lack of response is putting you in financial jeopardy or causing emotional stress, a lawyer can help expedite the process. They can advocate on your behalf to ensure you receive the compensation or coverage you’re entitled to, minimizing the impact on your life.
When You Suspect Bad Faith Practices – Insurance companies have a legal duty to act in good faith, which means they must handle claims honestly, promptly, and fairly. If your insurance company’s unresponsiveness feels intentional, it could be a sign of bad faith insurance practices, which may include:
- Ignoring valid claims to delay payment.
- Failing to investigate your claim thoroughly or at all.
- Denying your claim without explanation or justification.
- A lawyer can identify signs of bad faith and take action to hold the insurer accountable. In some cases, you may even be entitled to additional compensation for damages caused by the company’s unethical behavior.
When You Receive No Explanation for Delays – Insurance companies are required to provide clear explanations for any delays in processing your claim. If your insurer fails to communicate why your claim is stalled—or provides vague, inconsistent reasons—a lawyer can help uncover the root of the problem. They can also ensure that the company is not unfairly withholding payment or information.
When You Need Help Understanding Your Policy – Insurance policies can be complex, with dense language and detailed clauses that make it difficult to know exactly what you’re entitled to. If your insurer is unresponsive and you’re unsure whether your claim is being handled appropriately, a lawyer can review your policy, explain your rights, and ensure the company is meeting its obligations.
When Filing a Formal Complaint Isn’t Enough – If you’ve already filed a formal complaint with your state’s Department of Insurance and the company still hasn’t resolved the issue, legal assistance may be your next step. A lawyer can escalate your case, providing evidence of the insurer’s unresponsiveness and advocating for you in negotiations, arbitration, or court.
When the Stakes Are High – Certain claims involve significant financial stakes, such as those related to severe injuries, extensive property damage, or major liability disputes. If your insurance company is unresponsive in these high-stakes situations, the risks of not seeking legal help can be substantial. A lawyer can protect your financial interests and ensure you’re not taken advantage of.

How a Lawyer Can Help

Demand Accountability: A lawyer can contact your insurer on your behalf, often prompting quicker responses.
Review Your Rights: They can determine whether your insurer has violated Ohio’s insurance laws or acted in bad faith.
Pursue Legal Action: If necessary, a lawyer can file a lawsuit against the insurance company to recover compensation, including damages caused by their delays.
Provide Peace of Mind: Having a legal professional in your corner can reduce stress and give you confidence that your claim is being handled properly.

What to Look for in a Lawyer

When seeking legal assistance, choose an attorney who specializes in insurance law or bad faith claims. Look for someone with:

Experience: A proven track record in handling cases against unresponsive insurance companies.
Knowledge of Ohio Insurance Law: Familiarity with state regulations and deadlines.
Strong Communication Skills: Someone who can clearly explain your options and keep you informed throughout the process.

Are There Alternatives to Reach a Settlement Without Your Insurer’s Cooperation?

Yes. There are alternatives to reach a settlement, even when your insurance company refuses to cooperate. By understanding these strategies, you can take proactive steps to resolve your claim, protect your rights, and achieve the compensation you may be eligible to receive.

Negotiate Directly With the Other Party’s Insurance – If another party was involved in the incident (e.g., in a car accident), you may be able to bypass your insurer entirely and negotiate directly with the other party’s insurance company. Their insurer may be more cooperative if their policyholder was at fault.
- Steps to Take:
  - Collect evidence, such as photos, witness statements, and police reports.
  - Contact the other party’s insurer and file a third-party claim.
  - Be prepared to present your case clearly and assertively.
Mediation as a Dispute Resolution Tool – Mediation is an alternative dispute resolution (ADR) process where a neutral third party (the mediator) facilitates negotiations between you and your insurer. Mediation can be less formal, less expensive, and quicker than going to court. It’s especially effective if both parties are open to compromise.
- How Mediation Works:
  - Both sides present their case and concerns to the mediator.
  - The mediator helps explore possible solutions and guides the discussion.
  - While the mediator doesn’t make binding decisions, their recommendations often lead to settlements.
  - Mediation is voluntary, so your insurer must agree to participate. However, suggesting mediation can demonstrate your willingness to resolve the issue amicably.
Arbitration for a Binding Resolution – Arbitration is another ADR method, but unlike mediation, the decision made by the arbitrator is typically binding. This process involves presenting your case to an arbitrator, who acts like a private judge.
- When to Consider Arbitration:
  - Your insurer refuses to pay but there’s a clear disagreement over liability or the claim amount.
  - Your policy includes an arbitration clause, which requires disputes to be settled this way.
  - Arbitration can be faster than litigation, but it often waives your right to sue, so proceed carefully and consult an attorney before agreeing to arbitration.
File a Complaint with Your State’s Insurance Department – If your insurer’s lack of cooperation violates state regulations or deadlines, you can file a formal complaint with your state’s Department of Insurance. These agencies oversee insurance companies to ensure they follow the law and treat policyholders fairly.
- What to Include in Your Complaint:
  - A clear description of the issue.
  - Evidence of unresponsiveness or bad faith practices.
  - Copies of your correspondence, including unanswered emails or letters.
  - The Department of Insurance may investigate your complaint and apply pressure on the insurer to act. While this won’t guarantee a settlement, it often prompts insurers to cooperate to avoid penalties or bad publicity.
Seek Legal Representation – If your insurer continues to stonewall you, hiring an experienced insurance attorney may be your best option. Lawyers specializing in insurance disputes can review your case, identify bad faith practices, and take action to hold your insurer accountable.
- How an Attorney Can Help:
  - Demand a response from your insurer by leveraging legal expertise.
  - Negotiate directly with the insurer to reach a fair settlement.
  - File a lawsuit for bad faith insurance practices if your insurer is acting illegally or unethically.
  - In some cases, you may even recover damages beyond the value of your claim if your insurer’s behavior caused financial or emotional hardship.
Pay for Repairs or Costs Upfront and Seek Reimbursement – If delays from your insurer are preventing necessary repairs or medical treatment, you may consider paying for these expenses out of pocket and seeking reimbursement later. While this approach is not ideal, it ensures that you address urgent needs without waiting for your insurer’s cooperation.
- Tips for Seeking Reimbursement:
  - Keep all receipts, invoices, and proof of payment.
  - Document how these expenses relate to your claim.
  - Submit this evidence to your insurer when pursuing reimbursement.
  - If your insurer still refuses to reimburse you, this documentation can support your case in mediation, arbitration, or court.
  - Explore Small Claims Court for Smaller Disputes – For disputes involving smaller claim amounts, filing a case in small claims court may be a practical option. This approach allows you to represent yourself without the need for a lawyer, and the process is generally faster and less expensive than full litigation.
- When to Use Small Claims Court:
  - Your insurer denies or underpays a claim for a relatively small amount.
  - You have clear evidence that your claim is valid and reasonable.
  - Be sure to check your policy, as some contracts include clauses requiring arbitration or mediation instead of court proceedings.
Pursue a Bad Faith Lawsuit – If your insurer’s lack of cooperation is extreme—such as outright refusal to handle your claim or intentional stalling—it may qualify as bad faith insurance practices. Filing a bad faith lawsuit can not only compel your insurer to settle your claim but may also allow you to recover additional damages, such as compensation for emotional distress or punitive damages.
- Examples of Bad Faith Practices:
  - Denying a valid claim without explanation.
  - Deliberately delaying the claims process.
  - Misrepresenting policy terms to avoid paying.

An attorney can guide you through the process of filing a bad faith lawsuit and represent your interests in court.

Questions after a car crash?

What Are Some Preventative Tips for Better Communication with Insurers in Future Claims?

While dealing with insurers might not always be seamless, there are several steps you can take to establish clearer and more efficient communication for future claims. By being proactive and organized, you can lay the groundwork for a smoother claims process and avoid unnecessary frustrations.

Review and Understand Your Policy in Advance – One of the most effective ways to ensure better communication with your insurer is to understand your policy before an incident occurs. Familiarizing yourself with your coverage, exclusions, and limits can help you ask the right questions and provide the necessary information during the claims process.
- Actionable Tip:
  - Schedule a policy review with your insurance agent annually or whenever there’s a major life change (e.g., buying a new car, renovating your home). Use this time to clarify any confusing terms and confirm you have the right level of coverage.
Keep Your Insurance Information Accessible – When an unexpected event occurs, having quick access to your policy details and your insurer’s contact information can make all the difference. Scrambling for this information during a stressful time can lead to delays in reporting your claim.
- Actionable Tip:
  - Save your insurer’s phone number, email, and your policy number on your phone and in a physical location, such as a file or folder at home.
  - Consider using digital tools or apps provided by your insurer to access your policy and report claims quickly.
Document Everything from Day One – Strong documentation is the cornerstone of effective communication with insurers. From the moment an incident occurs, keep a detailed record of events, including photos, videos, receipts, and any correspondence with your insurer.
- Actionable Tip:
  - Use your phone to take pictures and videos immediately after an accident or loss. Capture as much detail as possible, such as damages, weather conditions, and injuries.
  - Maintain a log of phone calls, including the date, time, and name of the representative you spoke with, as well as a summary of the conversation.
Report Claims Promptly – Delays in reporting a claim can lead to unnecessary complications and may even jeopardize your ability to receive compensation. Insurers rely on timely information to assess damages and resolve claims efficiently.
- Actionable Tip:
  - Contact your insurer as soon as it’s safe to do so after an incident. Provide all requested details upfront to minimize back-and-forth communication.
  - Ask your insurer for a list of required documents to expedite the claims process.
Communicate Clearly and Concisely – When speaking or writing to your insurer, be clear and to the point. Overloading your adjuster with unnecessary information can lead to confusion and delays. Stick to the facts and focus on providing the information they need to process your claim.
- Actionable Tip:
  - Prepare a written summary of events before speaking with your adjuster to ensure you don’t forget critical details.
  - Avoid emotional language or speculation. For example, instead of saying, “I think the driver might have been texting,” say, “The driver appeared distracted and didn’t brake before impact.”
Stay Professional and Polite – While it’s easy to get frustrated during the claims process, maintaining a professional and respectful tone can go a long way toward fostering better communication. Remember, the representative you’re dealing with is more likely to help if you remain calm and cooperative.
- Actionable Tip:
  - Treat every interaction as a business conversation. Avoid raising your voice or making accusations, even if you’re upset.
  - If you feel like your concerns aren’t being addressed, politely request to speak with a supervisor.
Follow Up Regularly – After filing your claim, don’t assume everything is progressing on schedule. Claims can sometimes get delayed or overlooked, so proactive follow-ups are crucial to keeping the process on track.
- Actionable Tip:
  - Set reminders to check in with your insurer at regular intervals. Weekly follow-ups are often sufficient for most claims.
  - Send a follow-up email summarizing your conversation after each phone call. This creates a paper trail and ensures everyone is on the same page.
Use Digital Tools for Faster Communication – Many insurers offer apps, portals, or chat services that allow you to file claims, upload documents, and track your claim’s progress. Leveraging these tools can streamline the process and reduce the time spent on phone calls.
- Actionable Tip:
  - Download your insurer’s mobile app and explore its features before you need to file a claim. This ensures you’re familiar with the platform when the time comes.
  - Use online tracking tools to stay updated on the status of your claim without needing to call.
Be Honest and Transparent – Honesty is key when dealing with insurance claims. Providing inaccurate or incomplete information can slow down the process and even result in a denied claim. Insurers have processes in place to verify the details of your claim, so it’s better to address potential issues upfront.
- Actionable Tip:
  - If you’re unsure about a detail, say so. For example, if you’re uncertain about the exact time an accident occurred, state an approximate time instead of guessing.
  - Disclose all relevant information, even if you think it might negatively impact your claim. Transparency builds trust and credibility.
Know Your Rights and Responsibilities – Understanding your rights as a policyholder ensures you’re not taken advantage of during the claims process. Equally important is knowing your responsibilities, such as providing documentation or meeting deadlines.
- Actionable Tip:
  - Familiarize yourself with Ohio’s insurance laws and your policy’s specific requirements.
  - If you feel your insurer isn’t handling your claim fairly, don’t hesitate to escalate the issue, file a complaint with the Ohio Department of Insurance, or seek legal advice.

While insurance claims may never be stress-free, these preventative tips will help ensure you’re prepared and confident in handling whatever comes your way.

Should you require the additional assistance of a professional to advocate on your behalf, Injury Law Support provides a free connection to local, trusted Cincinnati lawyers that have experience dealing with insurance companies. Our service is free – simply fill out and send the “Free Case Review” form on this page and a member from our network will contact you shortly.

Trusted help is available.
Contact us today.

Free Case Review

No Upfront Fees. No Obligation.

"*" indicates required fields